Early premiere reactions for Practical Magic 2, which hits theaters September 10, 2026, have fueled trader optimism around a solid Tomatometer score. Critics at the London premiere praised the film’s nostalgic charm, humor, and seamless chemistry between Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman, with many calling it “perfection” for capturing the original’s sisterhood focus and magical tone. Some noted solid supporting turns from Joey King and Maisie Williams alongside the returning aunts, though a few flagged a slightly overlong runtime. With the sequel riding the first film’s cult status and strong pre-release buzz, these verified early responses position the market-implied odds around mid-50s to low-60s freshness, pending full critic reviews after wide release.